Published by Todd Bush on October 18, 2024
The US Supreme Court has denied requests from electric utility trade groups for an emergency stay of a final Environmental Protection Agency rule requiring 90% carbon capture at existing coal-fired power plants and new gas-fired generators by 2032.
This decision means that affected power generators will not need to start compliance work until June 2025, giving them time before the regulations take effect.
In a brief Oct. 16 order, Justice Brett Kavanaugh stated that applicants for the stay, including the Edison Electric Institute and National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, had shown "a strong likelihood of success on the merits" on at least some of their arguments against the EPA rule. However, he noted that because the regulations won’t require immediate action, the applicants are unlikely to suffer irreparable harm before the case proceeds.
"This court understandably denies the stay applications for now," Kavanaugh said in a statement joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch. "Given that the DC Circuit is proceeding with dispatch, it should resolve the case in its current term."
The Supreme Court's Oct. 16 order also noted that Justice Clarence Thomas would have granted the applications for stay, while Justice Samuel Alito did not participate in the consideration or decision on the applications.
The Edison Electric Institute (EEI), the nation's investor-owned utility trade group, argued that the EPA rule relies on unproven technology and contradicts the Supreme Court's recent Loper Bright decision, which limits deference to federal agencies. EEI raised concerns over the feasibility of carbon capture technology being adequately demonstrated.
The National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA) also argued that the rule violates the high court's major questions doctrine, which holds that agencies cannot regulate on matters of "vast political or economic significance" without clear authorization from Congress. This doctrine was cemented in the Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling against the Obama-era Clean Power Plan, which sought to transition the US away from coal-fired electricity.
In July, the DC Circuit rejected requests to stay the Biden administration’s EPA regulations, reasoning that petitioners failed to show a likelihood of success on claims that the EPA acted arbitrarily or capriciously in selecting carbon capture as the best achievable control technology for greenhouse gas emissions from power plants.
The trade group is disappointed by the Supreme Court's decision but will continue to press its case at the DC Circuit, said Alex Bond, EEI's executive director of clean energy and environment. "While EEI's member electric companies are investing in carbon capture and storage and are excited by its potential, the current reality is that this technology has yet to be adequately demonstrated as required by the Clean Air Act," Bond said in an email to S&P Global Commodity Insights.
Justice Kavanaugh noted that petitioners are free to ask the Supreme Court for review after the DC Circuit decides the underlying case in West Virginia v. EPA (No. 24-1120).
Follow the money flow of climate, technology, and energy investments to uncover new opportunities and jobs.
Inside This Issue 🏗️ Hyundai Unveils $6B Hydrogen-Powered Steel Mill in Louisiana, Aims to Position State as National Energy Leader 🤝 Deep Sky Inks Next DAC Deal in Germany with Greenlyte Carbon T...
Inside This Issue 🍁 Inside Canada’s Quiet Takeover of the Carbon Capture Industry ✈️ Phillips 66 to Supply SAF to British Airways in Calif 💧 HyVera Distributed Energy Launches Green Hydrogen-On-De...
Inside This Issue 🌍 1PointFive Announces 50,000 Metric Ton Carbon Removal Agreement with JPMorganChase 📊 Carbon Direct Unveils First Empirical Baseline on Carbon Dioxide Removal and Environmental ...
Approval in Principle (AiP) for World's First LCO₂ / Methanol Carrier
Tokyo, June 30, 2025 - Mitsubishi Shipbuilding Co., Ltd., a part of Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) Group, and Mitsui O.S.K. Lines, Ltd. (MOL) have acquired Approval in Principle (AiP)(Note1) fro...
KAIST AI Advances CO₂-Selective Material Discovery
_Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology_In order to help prevent the climate crisis, actively reducing already-emitted CO₂ is essential. Accordingly, direct air capture (DAC) — a techno...
Arca’s Carbon Removal Methodology Successfully Validated by DNV
Arca, a leader in carbon mineralization technology, has announced the successful validation by DNV, the independent energy expert and assurance provider, of its innovative methodology for permanent...
Massive Investment in Ascension Parish Targets Green Steel, Job Growth, and Hydrogen Infrastructure ASCENSION PARISH, La. — Hyundai has announced plans to invest $6 billion in a cutting-edge, hydr...
Follow the money flow of climate, technology, and energy investments to uncover new opportunities and jobs.